ARCHITECTURE
“Architecture
is both the process and product of designing environments for people
which reflect a range of practical and aesthetic considerations.
Urban
geography has a long history of examining architecture, initially
considering buildings as cultural artifacts and more recently as
objects of value, as sighs and in terms of the use and consumption
of architectural spaces by people.
In
an era of competitive globalization, iconic architecture is
increasingly being used as a tool for economic development within
cities. Increasingly, forms of “Fortress architecture” are
evident in cities, where people reside in secured access environments
exacerbating feelings of fragmentation and exclusion.” (Hall and
Barrett 2012)
The
following photo, is an example of “Fortress Architecture” - The
San Fernando Police Station.
San Fernando Police Station Presently - 2014. |
It
is not a modernist design, but was built during colonialism. Colonial
expansion by European nations led to the styles of classical Gothic which filtered back to the design of European buildings.
Not
much information is given about the San Fernando Police station, but
the foundation stone was laid around the 1870's and
bears
a similarity to the Former Police Headquarters located at the corner
of St Vincent and Sackville Streets in Port-of-Spain built in 1876.
“The
use of lancet windows and pointed arches framed in brick enclosing an
arcade, used as the main circulation corridor, reflect Italian Gothic
Revival. The grey stone would be limestone from the Piccadilly
Quarries in Laventille, the yellow bricks lining the arches are
yellow stock brick, probably used as ballast on ships or imported.
The
building is one of the most imposing on Harris Promenade with its
large tower, used initially as a lookout, and subsequently for radio
communication.On 17 February 2009, the station was gutted by fire. Restoration of the buildings is being considered.” (MacLean 2010)
Personally,
I can distinctly remember the day the “Old police station” was
burnt. Being a student of St. Joseph's Convent, San Fernando, and in
close proximity to the fire, we were evacuated and asked to gather on
the Harris Promenade. The following amateur video, captures this
event.
THE
DEVELOPMENT OF ARCHITECTURE:
Architecture,
first evolved out of the dynamics between human needs and means.
Until the technological era of development, there had been two major
ways of building. These include employing a frame covered with a
skin, or by putting one block on top of another.
Like
the development of the Police station, there were variations in early
building styles which resulted in the use of different materials.
These materials included, stone, clay, wood, skins, grass,
leaves,sand, and water. They have a profound effect on early
architectural forms, producing a wide variety of building traditions
around the world which played a major role in the development of
place identities. (Hall and Barrett 2012)
ARCHITECTURE
AND URBAN GEOGRAPHY
Geography
can be linked to architecture through rural landscape tradition of
cultural geography. Here natural landscapes were considered to be
transformed into cultural landscapes through human practices and
traditions indigenous to an area. (Hubbard 2006)
Jon
Goss (1988) in his paper explored four theoretical categories of
buildings: as cultural artifacts, as objects of value, as signs and as
a partial system. More recent work on architecture within urban
geography challenges those views of Goss by viewing the city as a
'text.' Thinking of the city in this fashion, urban geographers have
examined architecture and urban design as elements in the political
economy of urbanization, linked into the dynamics of urban change.
(Hall and Barrett 2012)
ARCHITECTURE
OF FEAR
According
to Hall and Barrett (2012), if iconic buildings and spectacular
developments represent the playful and carnivalsque side to post
modern urbanism, then fortress architecture represents its dystopian
side. The picture of San Fernando Police Station, incorporates this
type of architecture, in terms of the proliferation of security and
surveillance.
References
Hall,
Tim, and Heather Barrett. 2012. “The informal economy in Cities –
alternative economic spaces.” Urban
geography.
London: Routledge.
MacLean,
Geoffrey.
2010. “Built Heritage – Colonial.” Citizens
for Conservation Trinidad & Tobago. Accessed
April 10, 2014. http://citizensforconservationtt.org/main/index.php/builtherit/builtcolonial/110-san-fernando-police-station
I wonder if the police station was always used as such? While I agree that the solid brick structure seems fortress-like and suitable for a police station, I disagree to an extent about labelling it as such. It is after all, Italian Gothic, which is simply a style. It isn't really a controlled environment keeping unwanted persons out, but people should not be intimidated by a place that is supposed to provide help. If that's the case maybe it needs to be redesigned...
ReplyDelete